News:

Please read the Forum Code of Conduct   >>Click Here <<

Main Menu
Menu

Show posts

This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.

Show posts Menu

Messages - Ralph S

#1
Is the Dynamis controller getting a bad rap?
I performed a more in-depth search on the four models of EZ command controllers, I also did this for other manufacturers (not included here).   What I've concluded is that the EZ command (like everyone has been informing me) is a basic system.  Okay, great, I understand that based on the table below.  The controllers I have are the "discontinued" ones, or the catalog just doesn't list their model numbers.  The EZ Command Plus seems to have basically the same functions as my controllers.   

When I compare the Dynamis to the EZ Command there is a significant difference.  As one forum member indicated the Dynamis is a "Standard DCC system".  I take issue with that since, if you buy a "standard car" it will have four wheels, doors, and engine/motor, headlights, and maybe a radio.  The EZ command to me is that "Standard DCC system".  The Dynamis is an, for all practical purposes, an "Advance system".  Just like an "Enhanced Car" that has the standard features and also have GPS, Bluetooth, premier sound system, front and rear cameras, fancy keys for ignition, you get the picture.

So, in my travels around the US visiting the few model railroad clubs and asking questions about the controllers they use (of course, most know that answer) I'm still at a lost as to why the Dynamis isn't one of the controllers being used.

Dynamis vs EZ Command
|    select       |  E-Z Command  |     EZ Command      | Dynamis    | Dynamis Pro   
|                     |  (discontinued) |       (Plus)                 |                   |
         
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Max number |         2                |          2                     |     1            |      128   
of Cabs         |                          |                                 |                   |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Max number |         2                |          2                     |     1            |     128   
| of Addresses |                           |                                 |                   |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| 2 or 4 digit    |         2                |          2                     |     1            |    128   
Addresses    |                           |                                 |                   |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Consist          |       Max 3*         |            ?                   |     40          |      40   
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
|Speed Control|       Knob           |         Knob               |  Joystick     |  Joystick
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Current        |       1.0 Amp      |         1.0 Amp          |  2.5 Amp    | 4.0 Amp
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Support for    |        Yes              |        Yes                   |     Yes         |    Yes   
| Walkaround   |                           |                                 |                   |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| DC controller |        Yes              |        No                   |       ?         |     ?   
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Support for    |        Yes              |        Yes                   |     Yes         |    Yes   
|Power Booster|                            |                                |                   |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Support for    |        3 or 4          |       3 or 4               |    >4            |  >4 
|Sound Decoder|      functions     |    functions             | functions    | functions
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
| Accessory      |      Limited by     |     Limited by         |      ?             |    ? 
| decoder         |       Current         |     Current              |                    |
| Capability      |        capacity       |      capacity            |                    |
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------                 
| Number of     |        Max 10        |        10 or ?            | > 10            |  > 10 
| CV functions  |      functions       |       functions         | functions    | functions
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------           
| Wireless         |    No                   |        No                  |   Optional    |  Yes
| Capability      |                            |                               |                     | 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------           
| Computer      |        No                |        No                  |   Optional    |  Yes
| Control          |                             |                               |                     |   
| Capability      |                             |                               |                     | 
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------           
| Warranty       |       1 year           |         1 year             |    1 year       |  1 Year   
------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------                                   
Notes:  ? -indicates ambiguous information, unable to definitively determine
            > -indicates varying information sources, but definitely greater than the number given
            *  -indicates my experience with EZ command with 3 locomotives
          --- -Based on the Bachmann 2024 catalog, the Basic EZ command (model 44932 & 44901)
                 were deemed discontinued, replaced by EZ Command Plus


References:
This forum search "Dynamis".
Programming Long addresses With EZ Command
Converting to DCC.
Model Train forums websites - several
U-Tube search on "Dynamis"
Google search via European Model trains by Bachmann

PS. If you are wondering why I'm traveling down this path.  I am worried that the Bachman company might give up on advancing their basic controllers.  The EZ plus maybe just a step away from becoming an advanced version of itself.  I don't want Bachmann to can (quit) that advancement like they did the Walk-around.   

All opinions/corrections/etc. welcome...
 
#2
General Discussion / Re: Short Track
Today at 03:13:34 PM
The model numbers (44829 and 44899) that you were referring to are "N" scale track.
#3
General Discussion / Re: Comments please
Today at 03:01:03 PM
Well, this article/topic sure put a foot in my brain.  I thought Bachmann was an independent (US) company.   When researching other stuff regarding this post, I went to-Wikipedia: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kader_Group

This totally blew my mind.  I then went to my stock market metric- Reuters: https://www.reuters.com/markets/companies/0180.HK/

The stock advisor provides this info:  Target Advisor's own stock analysis of Kader Holdings Co Ltd is Bearish, which is based on 4 positive signals and 11 negative signals.  At the last closing, Kader Holdings Co Ltd's stock price was HKD 0.365. Kader Holdings Co Ltd's stock price has changed by -1.35% over the past week, +5.80% over the past month and -10.98% over the last year.  Current as of 5/16/2024 close.

Now I have a good idea why they discontinued the Bachmann EZ Command Walkaround. >:(
#4
General Discussion / Re: Reverse Loops
Today at 02:45:31 PM
There is an easier way to gap tracks for a return loop.  It's slightly more pricey but you don't have to cut EZ track.  Bachmann's 9-inch Terminal with Insulated Gap Track is easy to use.  It's model 44597.  The plus behind it, is you can still use it as a regular 9-inch straight track even with the gap, and that's just by closing the connections on it's bottom base.

Hope that helps.
#5
QuoteI believe the answer is yes to both questions.
I got that much, but what some of us ole Bachmann users would like to hear is, "Does the Dynamis user(s) consider this system worth its weight in gold, per say?"   U-tube on the Dynamis doesn't provide any incentives, from my point of view, with the exception that it does what those who have the "upgraded, or professional level, or the anti-knob systems have".

QuoteIf you want more than that, you have to get a more advanced DCC system.
Being the person that I am, I really like the basic system, it performs quite well, in that, all the extras do not seem to enhance by desires.  The little kids (and maybe one day my grandkids) really enjoy the simpleness of EZ command.  What I do have interest in, is the "Dynamis" and maybe its because it's directly compatible with the existing EZ command, or just that I may have an affection for Bachmann.   But what I do not understand is that my friends and even ones on this forum are pushing a change to the (what most call) "more advance" systems.
I comment on this same issue in Topic forum "Converting to DCC"
Performing a search on "Dynamis" on this forum provided some information.  According to topics in 2007, the Dynamis was introduced in Europe first, then sometime later introduced in the US.   The forum topics regarding Dynamis stopped in 2016. 

My curiosity may kill the cat, but why noone seems to support the Bachmann Dynamis system gives my that "why"?

There will be a continuation of this Dynamis discussion in a new forum topic.

 
#6
General Discussion / Re: Converting to DCC.
May 10, 2024, 04:33:32 PM
QuoteEZ command is basically DCC training wheels
Ok, I have to defend Bachmann on this one.  The EZ command is a basic DCC system, I'll admit that.  It's not a training system.  Yes, if you set the CV's on another system, the EZ command can support its use, provided one uses single digit CV's.  I've had the EZ Command for quite some time without issues.  My one sound locomotive works with the EZ command, not that I use it that much. 

Bachmann introduced the "Dynamis" system (I haven't bought it yet) but was looking into that system which does have the features that everyone seems bent on having.  (In another post, I ask for anyone that has the Dynamis to kinda give their thoughts on its use.  No response as of this post)

Disclaimer: I'm not professing that Bachmann is the greatest, nor the worse, and I'm not being paid to support or refute any Bachmann products. 

For additional info: Programming Long addresses With EZ Command    
#7
HO / Re: Speed Matching
May 10, 2024, 04:26:42 PM

Let me get this straight, consisting involves two or more locomotives on the same train with many train cars.  Consisting two or more locomotives on the same train with the locomotives placed in different locations of the train is also considered "consisting".   That is, one locomotive at the front, then another locomotive could be located in the middle, or at the back end of the train.  This is also considered consisting.  Is that correct, cause Wikipedia doesn't distinguish the locomotives.  https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Train#Terminology

Then when I run my dummy locomotives behind my powered locomotives, the dummy locomotives are called DIC (dead in consist)?
#8
This brings up a question.  The Bachmann (Model 36508) EZ Command Dynamis Wireless DCC System can handle multiple addresses?  That is, be programmed with long addresses?  Also the Dynamis also can program/control the multiple CV's like other manufacturers.

Inquiring minds would like to know are there any Dynamis users out there?
#9
I ran into this same problem where I wanted the EZ track to match up to a slight incline on my layout.  All of the EZ track short sections were either too short or too long.  This is where the Flex track comes in.  If it's a slight curve flex track can be cut to fit.  If it's a short piece of straight track then the Atlas straight track can be cut down to fit.  The best part is that the EZ track does not need to be modified.  That's right, you do not need to cut into the connector of the EZ track.  The atlas and flex track will attach directly to the EZ using a connector pin piece.  The other connector piece is supplied from the EZ track.
Financially, EZ track is expensive, the Atlas and Flex is much more economical and cutting them up to make EZ track fit in my view, provide the least expense.
Hope this helps.
#10
General Discussion / Re: Converting to DCC.
May 03, 2024, 07:37:18 PM
As always, I'm late to the conversation....
Quote...I have a few DC engines from back in the Jurassic that I'd like to run sometimes....
Quote...I understand why people want to try to keep partial DC, to keep locomotives they've already invested in. But really, it's like graduating from elementary school to high school....
My experience: If you have a large enough layout, you could keep both the DC and the DCC systems.  And yes, you could just install a DPDT switch as suggested, or separate the two electrical systems, DC and DCC from one another.  Two entirely separate tracks electrically isolated.  I wanted to keep my old "steam locomotives" which I hardly run, and the few DC diesels that I have, and they are on a separate (although short length of track).  This is what I call my museum pieces.  I can operate them, it's just that they don't go far.   My DCC track is the mother of all layouts and for the most part, I never left elementary school with the DC, but jumped directly to graduate school with DCC.  I will need you guys to let me know if I ever move from either elementary, high, or higher in this modeling career.

If you decide on the DPDT, make sure it's a "break before make" switch.  This will ensure the two power sources to not make contact with each other.   There will be an instance where someone will forget to turn off the power supplies and switch that DPDT. which is an accident waiting to happen.  Also understand that there are some models of DPDT switches that are made to make continuous contact when switching from one to source to another.  (Like switching systems from say, a DC battery supply to a DC power source.  It's called an uninterruptible power switching, where switching that DPDT switch does not cause a loss of power).
...and if you are wondering did I do that, no, but my kids did.  That's why I now have two separate power systems on my layout.
#11
HO / Re: Speed Matching
May 03, 2024, 07:24:17 PM
QuoteCan you imagine what would happen on the real railroads if the engineer had to keep running from unit to unit adjusting throttle settings?
That's why it's so much fun, it isn't a real railroad!  I know... real railroaders need that matching, remember they are doing it for efficiency and well human factors.  But since it's a model, having to make those adjustments manually adds to the excitement and actions that only the few "never been on/worked on a real railroad" can enjoy. 
This is the best part: With two engines addressed differently in a consist, one can speed up or slow down using different throttles.  In my case, I have the EZ controller and the other is the EZ walkaround (discontinued).  This may seem archaic to professionals (those who use those more fancy controllers) but having that basic speed knob makes it quite easy to control during consisting.  It can get really exciting when you hand one controller of  that consist to a kid.

I think I just learned a new term "doubleheading"!
#12
General Discussion / Re: Coupler Height Gauge
April 25, 2024, 04:48:32 PM
For those who are economically strapped, like myself, there is an alternative to purchasing the "Coupler height gauge".
If you are a user of the EZ track, the Bachmann Hayes Bumper (model 44791) from my experience, the actual bumper is a perfect way to determine if your car is at the correct height.  The Hayes Bumper stop should hit the coupler of the car in the center.  When it does that, you can be sure the car coupler height will be where it should be.
See gauge image in Topic (click for image)
or
use that Bachmann EZ track Hayes bumper.
 
#13
General Discussion / Re: Great vintage video
April 25, 2024, 12:54:26 PM
I'll say it again.  Thank goodness the Diesel engine has taken over; two-way radios are the norm, and three points of contact has been emphasized in the safety of personnel.
It's interesting noting the changes in safety of personnel from that time period to today, but we're still fighting today the risks people take in performing work.

Interesting video though.
#14
General Discussion / Re: EZ Track Feeder
April 25, 2024, 12:09:36 PM
The quick answer to your question is: Yes, you can daisy chain feeder tracks back to the original power source.

First Question to actually ask is, Do you really need the extra feeders?  If your EZ track is new, and the track connections are quite tight, then you may not need the extra feeders (This is based on how far the oval section is from the power source).  If you are experiencing locomotive slowing down, lights dimming when at the farthest from the power source, then adding a feeder at that far end is needed. (This also means that the track connection resistance is high). 

So, if extra feeders are needed that is easy to do with the rerailer (model 44502).  You may have to use the straight rerailer (model 44510) just before the curve track if you are using curved EZ track other than the 18-inch curve.

For these connections (simple diagram):

                          Track                                Track                                 Track
  Power }  ------- | |--------------------------- | |--------------------------- | |---------------------- for
source }   ------- | |--------------------------- | |--------------------------- | |--------------------- additional
                          Rerailer                            Rerailer                             Rerailer                              Feeders

Also ensure that the connectors are the correct polarity, that is, positive to positive and negative to negative.  Understand that the EZ track rerailers have connections on both sides of the track (roadbed) as shown in the simple diagram above.

Hope this helps.
#15
HO / Re: Speed Matching
April 24, 2024, 08:12:47 PM
Speed matching!  Doesn't it take the fun out of railroading?  Now if you talking about having two engines on the same track and you want these two to stay spaced apart as they move around the track, that's one thing.   But if you are using them in a consist configuration, that's where all the fun is.  You can take either the first and/or the second engine and manually control their speed as a part of the fun to keep them at an equal stance with one another.  The real fun comes in descending or ascending a grade where one will engine may need assistance to support the other.  To me that's a lot of fun keeping pace with the movement of the entire train, and it's an artist that can control both engines, keeping them from jerking along, but produce smooth movement.