Hal, being one of those "old men putting large cabs on HO mechs" I say Rubbish.      The new 4-4-0 is a great little engine that will be great to run and to modify (yep, the Old Man will be messing with it for sure).  All I can say is the On30 community is a lot better off with the offerings from Bach. since the first 2-6-0 was introduced.  I also believe another mfg. is coming out with a larger 4-4-0 in On30 so why should Bach. compete?

   Have fun with your S scale trains.

   Allen NYT