Here is the new topic threat for Season 19 of Thomas & Friends, which will be coming soon in 2015. Place any episode suggestions, predictions, episode reviews and possibly what classic series characters you want to see make a return. Enjoy!
One episode idea I have is 'Berth Brawl' to fix the problem with Duck and Emily at Tidmouth Sheds.
Sypnosis: When Tidmouth Sheds gets filled up again, a sad Emily joins with Duck, Donald, Douglas and Oliver on the Little Western. Duck tells her one of his stories from the GWR proving that he too had engine shed problems instigated by the larger GWR engines.
I heard that "Whale of a Tale and Other Sodor Adventures" is an upcoming US DVD that will involve new episodes from S19! I can't wait for that!!
http://www.walmart.com/ip/43987418 (http://www.walmart.com/ip/43987418)
An exclusive DVD at Walmart.
The episode titles no doubt are marine themed.
Quote from: Blackfive1994 on April 03, 2015, 12:41:02 PM
http://www.walmart.com/ip/43987418 (http://www.walmart.com/ip/43987418)
An exclusive DVD at Walmart.
The episode titles no doubt are marine themed.
That's what i ment
I want to see Donald and Douglas return, I don't see any reason why they wouldn't, even if they're a few more seasons away.
I also want some characters like Rosie to have a respectable role again... Some of the "new series" characters are personal favorites of mine. I think Rosie would benefit from the huge improvement in characterization we're seen these days. If Henrietta can gain a great personality, I don't see how any other character couldn't.
Maybe something about Toby being confident despite being old and on the weaker side. Perhaps a story line about all the engines getting easy jobs and only Toby getting his done because he doesn't put if off or underestimate it.
I'd also like to see Molly return, but that's a wish I'd accept if it never came true. It's hard to think of a practical reason she'd come back other than to reintroduce her to the current toy lines.
I feel like the show is better off without Rosie, as with other characters in the show they've been using a lot less. I think the show is focusing more on characters that allow them to have more potential for unique and interesting stories, which is why we've been seeing Toad get more attention than Oliver, or even Duncan being the only narrow gauge engine to get episodes in the 18th season. With characters like Rosie or Molly, there really isn't that much you can do with them.
Even the use of characters of the steam team has been more limited to some degree, as they've been giving characters like Paxton, Timothy, or Bill and Ben more roles, since with their unique personalities there is a lot more they can do with them. It's why we've been seeing Duck and James playing off against each other in season 18 since they're both fairly egotistical characters. When characters were forced into stories, much like in season 8-16, the episodes didn't work and the characters were forced to be flawed. When characters were given stories that worked naturally for them, like in seasons 1-7 and 17-18, they became much more effective.
Edward is a perfect example of a character who has been blatantly forced through audiences with weak episodes throughout 8-16. When season 18 came around with Old Reliable Edward, it became one of the best openers to a new season, as well as one of the best roles Edward had in a long time. It really shows that when they have an idea that works for an episode with a particular character, it works really well, and it works effectively! Hiro is another example of a character who had a poor portrayal in season 13-16, but both of his season 17 episodes are easily on my top 10 favorite episodes from that season, as both of them gave Hiro roles that were effective. I actually found Signals Crossed to be a decent episode as it gave Henrietta and Toby a unique role that made the characters work well together. That being said I would like to see Toby have a less-cowardly like role in the future, since that is something that made me cringe in the episode. Maybe if they allowed a flawed character like James or Samson to work with Toby and having Toby be a wise engine, much like in the classic series, I could see Toby potentially having a decent role in the future.
Say what you will about characters that haven't had starring roles recently, but I would rather wait until they can give a character a story that works with them, rather than having a forced plot like they have given other characters in season 8-16. I believe the show is working more towards quality when it comes to giving characters their own roles, not quantity. It would certainly be nice if other characters were given a chance for a storyline, but I would rather have two decent episodes starring Duncan, rather than 3 or 4 average episodes for the other narrow gauge engines. If characters were forced into the episodes like they were in previous episodes, the characters would become less interesting, as the stories have been around that era. This is a new generation of Thomas that has given us quality story-telling, and I believe that's what counts for more than anything with these episodes.
Sometimes I feel like Edward and Toby fall into the category of "not much you can do with," since it is true that being old and wise is only entertaining for so long. Of course, that would be the excuse of a poor writer, since a writer's job is to be creative and not rely on the go-to cliches.
James is one of the best characters so base stories on, because his personality drives the plot, not the surrounding circumstances. Regardless, I'm getting pretty irritated by him. A person can only screw up so many times before it stops being a form of youthful charm and starts to seem like a form of genuine stupidity. Like someone once said before, "I don't know why Sir Topham Hatt keeps him around anymore."
A good story for Toby in my opinion was "Baa," despite the goofy title. Toby uses his light weight to his advantage to cross and bridge that bigger, stronger engines could not. This also required bravery, and Toby wasn't forced by the others to do it. He was old and wise, but also brave and noble.
Quote from: DoggySporty on April 03, 2015, 10:38:23 PM
Sometimes I feel like Edward and Toby fall into the category of "not much you can do with," since it is true that being old and wise is only entertaining for so long. Of course, that would be the excuse of a poor writer, since a writer's job is to be creative and not rely on the go-to cliches.
I definitely agree with this, since there is so much you can do with that. I think that is why they are focusing on James since he is a character with his flaws, which makes him easier to explore for story-telling as opposed to Toby, Edward, or even Hiro for that matter.
I agree with you on your point with "Baa" too, I feel like that an episode like that for Toby is long overdue, but as I suggested earlier it would work well with a character who is flawed. Bulls Eyes is another perfect example of where Toby had a perfect role with a character who also had her flaws as well, Daisy.
I guess if there is another character who I would be interested in seeing return at some point is Arthur. I feel they could pull off a decent story with Arthur if they were to make him a returnee since he has his own branch line. I mentioned the idea of Arthur pulling the flying kipper for an episode, and I feel that could really work out. I've always liked Arthur more than Murdoch, or even Fergus, which is why I'm hoping he'll be the next character to return non-Awdry wise. Though I could see how it might be harder to do a story with Arthur, besides the idea I mentioned, simply because Arthur's persona is nowhere close to flawed and might not have much to explore besides a few appearances every now and again like Oliver. Hopefully we can see something from him soon. He's not just one of my favorite characters, but even the Bach-man himself has mentioned to me that he likes Arthur!
I just wonder if they would do an episode where Henry explains about how he came to his new shape and used flashbacks of him in his old shape. What do you think? Does this sound possible or is it wishful thinking?
or even explain that the fat controller's nickname was originally the fat director.
Also, what is the address for hit entertainment as I want to suggest these to them.
Quote from: JLK2707 on April 04, 2015, 05:56:26 AM
Also, what is the address for hit entertainment as I want to suggest these to them.
http://www.hitentertainment.com/corporate/contact.aspx (http://www.hitentertainment.com/corporate/contact.aspx)
all contacts for HiT are on this link.
Quote from: JLK2707 on April 04, 2015, 05:44:18 AM
I just wonder if they would do an episode where Henry explains about how he came to his new shape and used flashbacks of him in his old shape. What do you think? Does this sound possible or is it wishful thinking?
I think it sounds reasonably plausible, but I can't say I'd place any bets on it. It would be nice to see though!
Quote from: Chaz on April 03, 2015, 09:10:05 PM
I feel like the show is better off without Rosie, as with other characters in the show they've been using a lot less. I think the show is focusing more on characters that allow them to have more potential for unique and interesting stories, which is why we've been seeing Toad get more attention than Oliver, or even Duncan being the only narrow gauge engine to get episodes in the 18th season. With characters like Rosie or Molly, there really isn't that much you can do with them.
The same could be said about Stanley, too me, he feels like a bland Thomas clone. It's not that Rosie and Stanley are bad characters, but they've seem to have been relegated into cameos. The Shunting Yard in the show is kinda like a dumping ground, nowadays. You would see Rosie, Stanley, Charlie, and Stafford there. Pretty clever way to utilize them. You have the S17-present characters that are developed/or developing that have strong personalities. Look at characters like Marion. Though the S13-16 characters did get a second chance. However I think Hiro was the gem worth salvaging. He has been my favorite CGI character, now tied to Marion. It's good to see that Hiro's character was done justice. He's had great roles ever since. It shows that the old can mix well with the new.
I completely doubt that the S17-18 characters replaced the classic characters.
They seem to fill the shoes of the 'missed opportunities with lost potential' especially the ones from S9-12
Derek, Thumper, Bertrem, Neville, Dennis, Mighty Mac, Billy, Hank, etc.
As for Classic Returnees.
(Donald/Douglas are off the list, since they've been confirmed.)
Boco-This character has never had a starring role, however he would make a contribution to the character formula.
Daisy-Despite having few roles, she's a well-developed character, there's so much story arc that you could do with her. However I hope that the sexist accusations don't get in the way of her making a comeback.
Terrance-Well this character can make a potential contribution with the road characters.
Stepney-Well given that the general opinion over Stepney is divided. I would say go for it with a comeback. It would be fun if we got to see him interact with Stephen, bantering off one another.
Murdoch-I think this character has potential for a comeback, S7 has introduced fantastic characters and they each served a purpose. With Murdoch, imagine how epic of a duo he and Hiro would make being powerful goods engines.
Arthur- Like Murdoch, I think he deserves a comeback, I think that there's alot that the writers can do with them, say one of the current writers wrote starring episodes for Arthur. Plus what's the Fishing Village without Arthur?
Quote from: JLK2707 on April 04, 2015, 05:44:18 AM
I just wonder if they would do an episode where Henry explains about how he came to his new shape and used flashbacks of him in his old shape. What do you think? Does this sound possible or is it wishful thinking?
What about season 1 troublesome trucks? Good idea to give it a go or wishful thinking?
Perhaps. I had just never thought of this whatsoever. What's next? Going back to the original model animation?
Do I just have to contact hit entertainment directly to suggest ideas for future specials/episodes/movies?
Quote from: JLK2707 on April 05, 2015, 04:42:06 AM
Do I just have to contact hit entertainment directly to suggest ideas for future specials/episodes/movies?
Try Arc too, but they would not accept unsolicated ideas.
Okay. Thanks for the reply, but have you ever tried to contact them with episode ideas?
not as yet.
In my opinion, these are the possible characters to return in S19:
-Donald and Douglas
-Rosie (Speaking Role)
-Boco??
Quote from: DoggySporty on April 03, 2015, 10:38:23 PM
Sometimes I feel like Edward and Toby fall into the category of "not much you can do with," since it is true that being old and wise is only entertaining for so long. Of course, that would be the excuse of a poor writer, since a writer's job is to be creative and not rely on the go-to cliches.
I guess it depends. We did see in The Adventure Begins that Edward did have flaws, but they were ones we could find acceptable, and honestly, they are ones that could be used for an episode or two. Toby, too in this case.
I could honestly see an Edward or Toby episode that could do any of these things:
1) The character tries his best to solve a problem but overthinks it with no progress, then finds an ingenious solution. This was done to a degree in Edward, Trevor and the Really Useful Party.
2) The character's kindness is not in the right direction and realizes that the not so kind way is the right way.
3) Interacting with a character with flaws they haven't exactly dealt with before. I for one think that this is where Molly could be used. She is a shy character, and well, I can't really think of a time when a wise engine has dealt with a shy character before. Arrogant, reckless, inexperienced, and troublesome - yes, but not shy.
There's also still plenty of potential to use classic characters that haven't really interacted with one another before. I can honestly imagine a good episode with Oliver and Diesel in the focus, as well as Daisy and Mavis. Not to mention a roadway episode is one that could be a breathe of fresh air. I will agree with Chaz that some ideas have to be more than just an unusual character choices to work with one another, though, and it is important to look into the episode more thoroughly if they want it to work with these certain characters.
yeah like Toby had trouble with Mavis when she first arrived because of her headstrong ideas. So have an episode where Toby ends up with a problem at Ffarquhar Quarry that only Mavis knows the solution to and not him.
Quote from: Blackfive1994 on April 06, 2015, 02:20:30 PM
yeah like Toby had trouble with Mavis when she first arrived because of her headstrong ideas. So have an episode where Toby ends up with a problem at Ffarquhar Quarry that only Mavis knows the solution to and not him.
Idk if they would do an episode like that. I could see them have Toby and mavis working together, until some problems occur at the quarry.
Quote from: MeganekkoFury1126 on April 06, 2015, 02:17:40 PM
I will agree with Chaz that some ideas have to be more than just an unusual character choices to work with one another, though, and it is important to look into the episode more thoroughly if they want it to work with these certain characters.
I think everyone feels that way. That's just how story telling works.
Exactly! Does it also just sound plausible for Henry to be in his old shape permanently (as if the flying kipper crash never happened) whilst the current Henry model is scrapped or would kids not understand whatsoever?
Quote from: JLK2707 on April 07, 2015, 09:46:13 PM
Exactly! Does it also just sound plausible for Henry to be in his old shape permanently (as if the flying kipper crash never happened) whilst the current Henry model is scrapped or would kids not understand whatsoever?
(https://keumars.files.wordpress.com/2014/05/lion-facepalm.jpg)
They are not changing Henry's shape back to his former shape. Henry's current shape is by far more iconic than the older design, and I can't see that changing or getting "scrapped" anytime soon. We didn't even see his old shape in the Adventure Begins, and I think that is saying something about the possibility of them going back to the old shape, even for a flashback.
Sorry for that. I understand. It's also quite unlikely they'll do Gordon green too.
What else I would like to just suggest about Henry's current shape is basically modifying the windows a little bit to make them look more like a literal black 5 rather than them having the windows on the front of his cab being obscured by the belpaire firebox.
I always wondered how his crew saw out those tiny windows. ;)
Can people stop double posting, not to clog up this thread?
Anyway, With Old-Shape Henry, my exceptions are next-to-never. CGI rendering isn't like modeling Hornby/Bachmann. Adding an accessory like a lamp is a simple outside detail, but if you were to convert Henry into his Old-Shape, you can't just simply cut-out the firebox in CGI as you could with a solid object. See Henry's firebox is a part the entire render that makes up whole piece. Changing the livery is a simple modification in color coding, like we've seen with Black James, or Blue Bill/Ben. However, with Henry's Old-Shape in CGI, you would have to start over from an entire new render. ???
I studied Digital Arts and Animation for a semester. ::)
CGI and Live-Action Models are completely different aspects.
I think Arc's Animation Budget is better spent rendering a completely different character whether it's a classic or new.
Personally, I think that Henry's Old Shape is a big deal, but then again "Why didn't Henry get a Black 5 tender with his New-Shape?"
Humorously, though I couldn't tell the difference between Old-Shape Henry, until I've seen a Bachmann conversion. :P
I'm very sorry about my repetitive posts. Please just forgive me for it. I didn't mean to annoy you.
For years I thought of an episode where Annie and Clarabel get a chance to travel behind Gordon instead of Thomas, but we now have this episode, only instead of Gordon they are pulled by Caitlin. I always wanted Annie and Clarabel to have an episode to themselves and Brenner delivered!
Another episode I have thought of, which to my knowledge hasn't been made yet, is an engine needing repairs and being afraid to go the the Steam Works because they've never been there before. Yes, you'd need a new character to fill this role, but the new character could be anyone lacking the arrogant personality archetype. It could be a sort of parallel to kid being afraid of going to the hospital or dentist for the first time, yet still have roots in railway themes.
If this episode does happen to be made, I just hope Toby doesn't get the role.
With all this talk about Rosie and Stanley, I hardly hear people bring up Whiff, personally I think he's an overlooked character. He had a one-off introduction in the model series, however in the CGI era, he became more fleshed out, especially in "MIR" when he was the best character in the movie, IMO. Plus he's at least given a purpose running a waste dump. He would make a great play-off character, give him an episode with James, Diesel, or maybe Samson. Whiff's character seems to the most appealing out of the S9-12, it's shown that there's more from him then what lies behind his glasses. ;)
5 new episodes for Season 19 that were announced!!
-Toad and the Whale
-Who's Geoffrey?
-The Truth About Toby
-Lost Property
-A Spot of Bother
Also, any predictions for the new engine, Geoffrey?
-Tim
och that truth about toby looks like its going to dive into his past well fingers crossed anyway
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=VwbKKViBBkI
Looks like our first slice of season 19 is out in the open! Not sure what episode this is from, but already we've seen even more improvement in Arc's animation.
Not a fan of the Sodor Search and Rescue stuff, personally.
Luckily, we got a clip of Whale of a Tale, which is the shows first Little Western story in years:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=p5dEulTKIhU
I think that team is really getting the chemistry between the 3 Great Western's that I feel was a little unfulfilled in the classic era. So, I'm glad they're delving into it for this episode when it fully comes out.
Whether you're a fan of the Search and Rescue Center or not, I will admit that I would use that scene at the beginning of the clip as a portrait to hang on my wall, it looks absolutely stunning.
I also like the scene with Harold saving a civilian from a flood, maybe not as climatic, but compared to what's happened S13-16, it's better than having him saving drifting party balloons. Also it seems like Belle/Flynn are staying in the show. However between Rosie or Belle, is it wrong to say I would rather see Belle over Rosie? At least she's not having 'What girls like' quota. :P
Anyway, now the real thing
Other then Oliver's scaling, which I'm not to bothered much, though, I'm sure Arc will fix it in a season or two. It's great to see the Great Western duo having a story. I wonder if Donald/Douglas will appear.
The Little Western scenery is starting to look more coastal. I can't help but laugh at Toad's singing. ;D
I liked both of the clips that were revealed so far. Oliver's line "This is what happens when Toad is in a good mood" was pretty funny in regards to Toad's singing. Perfect comeback to the singing too I'll admit. Even the Search and Rescue center clip looks interesting, and I thought the animation was stunning with Harold flying all over different parts of the railway. I give both of the clips two thumbs up, and hopefully the episodes will be as promising as the clips are.
That and these DVDs will be out right as I'm finishing college so that's some extra motivation for me to get through these next couple of weeks!
If Daisy and Diesel 10 were to pull anything whatsoever, what would it be?
Quote from: JLK2707 on May 23, 2015, 07:03:21 AM
If Daisy and Diesel 10 were to pull anything whatsoever, what would it be?
A milk tanker of course :D, Dairy van if it's RWS logic though :P ...I'm sorry I couldn't help the urge to make that reference
~Alex
Well, with the first 5 season 19 episodes out now, we can all express opinions on them now. So, here we go.
Toad and the Whale
Arguably the most anticipated episode of the 5. I was a little worried I admit, that it would be too much like Toad's Adventure or Toad's Bright Idea. But it indeed was something fresh! I think this is the closest the show will get to animal death, and they handled it very well. The writers also seem to have done their homework about whale biology. I think the best thing new writer Helen Farrall got down was the relationship between Oliver and Toad, which was arguably better handled in this episode compared to Toad's Adventure. I didn't mind Thomas' role in this episode, though I still think his role could've gone to some engine else. Additionally, all the Search & Rescue members were handled nicely, especially Belle. I must say she's really grown on me now. I guess it helps she's in better writing hands. Though, I'm a little confused how Butch would "tow" the whale considering how it was edited, I don't know... All in all, it's a pretty sweet yet serious episode, and really handled Oliver and Toad wonderfully. 9/10
The Truth About Toby
For those who really wanted Toby back to his original personality, you've got it! This episode is another good example that putting a face on Henrietta was a great idea. The interaction between her and Toby felt so appropriate, and I'll take Toby in his somewhat stubborn and easily irritated attitude over the Barlow era wimp attitude any day. I liked how Reg was handled here as well, though, the scene of him picking up Toby and throwing the car across the lines did feel a little over the top. I also feel Edward learning about the rumor twice didn't make sense. But compared to what mistakes were done in Barlow episodes, they're nothing. In fact, I'll say this is season 9's Thomas and the New Engine done correctly, especially how much better the moral of not to spread rumors was delivered, as it felt so well paced throughout. I'm gonna give this one a 8/10.
Who's Geoffrey?
Arguably, this is my favorite of the new 5 episodes. A very nice slice of life episode we have here. It seems they really work nicely for Thomas focused episodes. I'm sure this episode's moral will be the most relatable to children who watch it - trying to blame their mistake on a made up person. The pacing of this episode was great. I especially like how well paced it was how Thomas continually lied about Geoffrey, and how it was spread to the amount of characters involved. I think the best parts were both Sir Topham Hatt telling Thomas the right thing to do with his own experiences, and Thomas pulling off a "Kermit the Frog" voice in the tunnel. I really like Percy's new voice they obtained, it sounds much more appropriate for him, just like James' new one. If there's something I didn't really like, is the ending. I'm not quite sure what they were trying to tell, since we don't actually see what mistake Thomas does at the end. Well, that and how odd the crossing gates acted when Bertie was crossing. They're a bit confusing to me, but honestly not a particularly bad thing in an otherwise great episode. 9/10.
Henry Spots Trouble
I know A LOT of people who are not going to like this episode. I for one am a bit split. What good it did was really good, but the big elephant in the room IS what does bring the episode down for me. I know a lot of people complain that Henry is the only one of the classic characters who hasn't come close to being restored to his original personality - a high strung complainer. Whilst I feel he was correctly in character in Henry's Hero, I do admit it confuses me why they haven't done it yet, and it is a little troubling that they're going to stick with Henry being a worrier. That being said, the way the episode was handled was extremely relatable. The old saying of what "we don't understand, we fear" used as the plot is handled very properly, as well as Sir Topham Hatt explaining them at the end. Davey Moore once again shows how good he is at writing humor in this episode. My favorite moments are when Connor splashes Gordon with red paint and the painter walks awkwardly away. Gordon's reactions are absolutely priceless. Oh yeah, and Sir Topham Hatt doing a SpongeBob mistake. I'm really happy that Stephen and Bridgette were in this episode, and they really worked for it extremely well. The same could be said for Paxton. He once again is showing to be one of my favorite newer era characters. So, in the end, it's not a bad episode, even if Henry is not how we originally knew him as. It's amazing how the lesser good episodes in the Brenner era don't even come close to the bad episodes of the Barlow era. 5.5/10.
Lost Property
Yet another solid slice of life episode. Helen Parrall is really showing to be a very talented writer on the show already with this episode and Toad and the Whale. Once again, the pacing is well executed. Not the best, but still good. Good build up at the beginning, nice play out in the middle, and the ending where everything comes full circle. I can say the episode isn't exactly the most exciting episode overall, but it doesn't make me dislike the episode at all. The way Thomas and Sir Topham Hatt run into one problem after the next on the most unfortunate of days is not only funny to watch, but extremely relatable. We all have those days where we feel things just keep getting worse when we least want them to. Sir Topham Hatt getting angry at the obnoxious little boy was extremely funny, as well as Annie's reaction. I can easily see this episode being pulled off the pages of the Railway Series. 8/10
So, what do you all think? I think season 19 is on to a pretty good start, and I eagerly await the next episodes coming out later this year! No spoilers of returning characters yet, nor any spoilers to Sodor's Legend of the Lost Treasure yet, which I think is a good thing. I can't get over the beautiful improved animation and am anticipating the return of more old favorites as well as the new characters being used.
hahahaha love the whos Geoffrey episode really loving the righting on the new season and I spyed with my little eye that spencer was wearing LNER headlamps nice touch ARC ;D ;D ;D
Well, might as well keep updating this thread.
Wild Water Rescue
Honestly, this episode really exceeded my expectations. We have another great story from a new writer, in this case Becky Overton. Remember how well the Percy and Diesel dynamic worked in past episodes, even in the Barlow era? Well, it worked just as well here. It was a nice turn of events that Diesel actually succeeded in his trick for once and got his picture taken, but definitely not in the way he wanted. It's definitely a nice twist where Percy doesn't automatically win and Diesel doesn't automatically lose. I'm glad they made use of Emily's coach renders for more rolling stock by ARC. I really liked the gloomy scenery animated for the old quarry, and Percy's accident is very reminiscent of Percy's Promise. I really can't think of a moment that I didn't like at all! Really I don't! 10/10
Where did you see this one??
https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=DaFGVIhUfVk
It's online right now. :)
I just wonder when the new episodes for season 19 come out.
I'm glad about what I'm seeing. The Little Western is starting to feel more coastal, more like the GWR lines in Britain. I've thought the whale serving as the catalyst, was a great idea. Toad in CGI, has become one of the most intellectual and resourceful characters in the show. It's at least a good thing the Search and Rescue didn't consider using explosives.
"Who's Geoffrey" ought to be a very weird episode, it's something that rarely happens in the show. But I loved it, especially Thomas' Geoffrey impersonation gave me a laugh. I actually prefer the characters this way.
Reg himself, despite being a stationary character, is a really enjoyable one. As for Henrietta, well I now think that giving her a face was actually a great idea for the show, she's not a pet rock, and the way she plays off Toby makes it feel like they're like an old couple. When the engines were spreading rumors about Toby's demise, notice how mournful the dialogue sounded. Makes me wonder what the tone might be in the future.
With Henry, well....I think his worrisome persona would work better if he'd fear breaking down, take "Henry's Hero" for example, being one of Henry's strongest episodes. But with a human disease, it doesn't seem to work so much to me. However my biggest gripe with the episode is the humor that revolves around STH/TFC. In this season, it really feels forced, especially the "ripped paints" sequence. It might be me, though. I did however get a laugh, at the paint scene, as if Gordon ran over a damsel in distress.
The Search and Rescue Team, they've grown on me, I can tolerate them now. Even though they're still in the show, it's better seeing what they're doing now, compared to "Fireboxes on Fire."
Honestly, I felt the exact same way when I saw Henry Spots Trouble. Even though I haven't done reviews on here as much as I used to (MeganekkoFury1126 seems to be doing a good job of doing that for me it seems :P), this one would easily be at the very bottom on my favorite episode list from this season. Judging by the general reaction I've seen from other fans, it's clear I'm not the only one.
Forced humor is never funny, especially when it doesn't contribute anything to the episode. The scene where Sir Topham Hatt ripped his pants was honestly one of the most cringe-worthy moments I think the show has had in a long time. Even though I felt the episode was already weak to begin with, that moment just killed it for me. I can always let humor slide every now and again, like in Lost Property or even the shed gag in Duck and the Slip Coaches, even if arguably the last one triggered a few fans, I can at the very least see why the writers included that moment. However, I can't find myself saying that for what was shown in Henry Spots Trouble. It was a little over-the-top and really distracting in the episode. Glad to see I'm not the only one who didn't find that moment funny.
Apart from that episode though, I'd say the rest of the episodes were decent. The Truth About Toby is easily my favorite so far this season as it was great to see such a variety of characters involved as well as this being one of the first good Toby episodes in a long time. I dare say the last decent Toby episode we got was in season 6! I feel Wild Water Rescue deserves a mention from me too, since I honestly thought this episode was going to be horrible since I thought it was going to be another Belle/Flynn episode that we would have to sit through. This though, was phenomenally better than I thought it was going to be and I think Percy and Diesel's relationship is explored so much better in this episode than it was in Percy and the Calliope.
Overall, I have to say that this season is definitely off to an interesting start and I am interested in seeing where the rest of the season goes from there.
Excuse me, this might just be a bit irrelevant, but I am wondering if the brake van with a face from a close shave was indeed the spiteful NW brake van with a different face.
the writers did a rather good job with Duke the lost engine. but after seeing the CGI you never see him again. he is a very key character to the narrow gauge locomotives. having saved Sir Handel (falcon on the old railway) and taught all the others.
Thanks Chaz, I figured that since the season's already out, anyone's opinion is better than none at all. :)
And to be honest, my opinion on that episode has gotten worse as time went on, watching it again and again, and I can see all the other reasons why it didn't work.
As for Duke, who knows? Maybe he will make a return. If Daisy could come back and a coffee pot engine was introduced to the series, I think anything's possible. We've already gotten a lot of good things back, so I think it's best not to get spoiled. Besides, the writers probably should take their time if they want to adapt him in while sticking more true to the Railway Series.
And Sir Handel? Actually, I would LOVE a Sir Handel episode in this season, or any future one. With Brenner and the rest of the new writers, I think that they could easily write an episode where Sir Handel is back to his selfish, irritated self like he was in season 4. If they could do two great episodes with Duncan last season, I don't see why this can't be done. :)
Hopefully they'll bring back the TAR tanker wagon in CGI! I would just love to see that! :)
Seems that we got more of S19 news.
(https://pbs.twimg.com/media/CLnJGumWIAEvVdI.jpg:large)
This time a female based episode. Caitlin sure seems to overshadow Connor, kind of a shame really because I love NYC Hudsons, but nonetheless, I'm sure it well trun out great.
Rather then the Classic characters returning and getting a handful of episodes, it's also good to see Brenner/Mccue give as much dedication to their own characters as they do with the Classics.
Do share your thoughts. :)
Huh, this does look interesting, especially the former.
As much as I do like the classic returnees getting their own episodes again, it's good to se the new team put in just as much emphasis on the newer characters so no one is left out.
I agree about Connor, I do prefer him, but I do like Caitlin as well, and she is interesting. It looks like a real girl power episode is in store for her and Emily. This I welcome as girls should be treated just as important on the railway as the boys just like in real life, and it'll be interesting to see the two females go speed against splendor.
As for the story on Thomas and Spencer, I'm a little dubious. We've seen times where Thomas and Spencer interact that turned into duds (E.G. Topped Off Thomas) or just turn out okay (Dream On). But considering this is the new team doing it, I'm going to give them the benefit of the doubt.
Quote from: MeganekkoFury1126 on August 05, 2015, 06:53:16 PM
As much as I do like the classic returnees getting their own episodes again, it's good to se the new team put in just as much emphasis on the newer characters so no one is left out.
With the CGI characters they're actually quite appealing. They're much better developed and feel like actual characters compared to the characters from S9-16. Though in S17, half of it revolved around giving the S13-16 characters a second chance.
With Charlie and Stafford, well it's good to see them try but they both fell flat. I will say that Charlie's ep was pretty clever. But nowadays it's at least a good thing he's in the Shunting Yard. ;)
With Scruff, it was a pretty unique "Harvey Dent" scenario.
As for Belle/Flynn, for them, I'd say it was fair. Though personally, I'd prefer Belle over Flynn, character-wise. However it's save to say that their use and purpose has at least become much more logical, compared to their roles from the previous era. So I'm fine with that. I actually can tolerate an 4MT with fire hoses, then inbred stereotypes.
But I think Hiro came out the strongest, both his episodes are equally my favorites of S17.
Personally out of the characters from the previous era, I'd keep; Hiro, Victor, Paxton, and Luke.
But it's at least a good thing on how the others are utilized to make them at least tolerable.
Does anybody just happen to know when the new episodes of season 19 are coming out?
Quote from: JLK2707 on August 27, 2015, 12:34:17 AM
Does anybody just happen to know when the new episodes of season 19 are coming out?
Maybe this Winter or earlier?
Well, looks like season 19 will finally be picking up the pace.
These next episodes will be released in the US on October 13th (iTunes) and 27th (DVD).
Diesel's Ghostly Christmas Parts 1 & 2
Snow Place Like Home
A Cranky Christmas
The Beast of Sodor
Plus these three to release on November 24th.
Very Important Sheep
Salty All At Sea
Den and Dart
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=XXQKCQnUzEA
We have a little preview for one of the Christmas episodes that will release on DVD this October. Can only imagine what Sir Topham Hatt did this time...:P
I'm really enjoying what I'm seeing in S19, but I'm not really liking the audio used in the recent US releases, compared to the UK broadcast, the US audio has been sounding distorted.
Well it looks like while today has not only been the first day of season 19 airing in the UK, it turns out we are finally getting a new opening as well as a new roll call and ending:
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=koxy8Dsz7_Q
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Ah7xge7JIW4
An improvement compared to the last one? I sure say so!
Wow! Really like them both. And love that he's at Ffarquhar in the credits.
I'm loving how the new intro has a much broader variety of characters both Classic and CGI outside the Core Cast. I even find the new Roll Call much more bearable than the original.
As for Percy's New UK Voice, I'm actually liking it, it really defines Percy, much more than Keith Wickham, even though he's a talent voice actor.
Gordon, Henry, Edward, Skarloey, which I think are his best ones, they really need to lighten his load a bit. The voices he's doing aren't really contrasting
E.G: Bert (Arlesdale), and Sir Handel's voices aren't interesting.
Do you think that they should have the mail coaches and tankers revert to the wording rather than having the logos?
Quote from: JLK2707 on September 25, 2015, 09:32:56 PM
Do you think that they should have the mail coaches and tankers revert to the wording rather than having the logos?
I think they should, 100% Yes.
Maybe even have the logo they have now, just with some text on/under/over it :P
Have you seen this video. Got preview clips for forthcoming Season 19 episodes.
http://youtu.be/rfSixccU1E0 (http://youtu.be/rfSixccU1E0)
Well, we got another season 19 episode out in the open! So let's get to breaking it down.
SPOILERS
The Beast of Sodor
I was worried that this would stink.
Thankfully I was wrong...for the most part.
There is a very noticeable three strike formula, much like Flatbeds of Fear, mostly in Henry believing everything he sees ahead is the monster. And yes, Henry is still the cowardly version we've been getting still. However, this one is a lot better than Henry Spots Trouble because Henry is getting teased actively by someone, but he's the one who comes out on top in the end, and that he does prove to be brave and not a complete wuss. Besides, Henry does take the opportunity to jab back at Spencer, much like in the classic era with James or Percy.
Sir Topham Hatt getting played for comedy has been getting really REALLY common this season, but for this episode, it does work. His sequence of events are very well put together. We've probably felt very disoriented in a potentially stranded situation in very snowy weather. And how Sir Topham Hatt went from one bad situation to the next did remind me of Lady Hatt's Birthday Party from season 5. Not to mention the bull scene reminded me of Gordon and the Gremlin.
Spencer being the antagonist has been done before, but compared to past examples, he's not made a straight up jerk when he bursts his safety valve, and does ask Henry to help him. Speaking of which, when's the last time an engine burst their safety valve? Much too long...
Oh yeah, and that horror music and needle scratch being played for laughs worked really well. I hope season 19 continues to throw more surprises at me like this one did.
8/10
And did you know the horror music cue is used in spongbob.
That music has actually been used in a lot of cartoons, like the Simpsons and Futurama.
Snow place like home is on YouTube now.
Not sure what to say about how the ep will turn out, but look who's in the clip.
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=7k8dXcd9cRE&feature=youtu.be&a=
I'm gonna post my thoughts on the Christmas eps later when my homework is out of the way.
TREVOR!!!!
Well, I guess it was only a matter of time we'll see him again, since his CG render was done by Nitrogen - albeit for a very brief cameo.
But I really hope they use him for speaking roles now!
Glad to see Trevor being brought back, well besides the intro and season 15 cameo. It'd be interesting to see if they would develop him further, or at the very least speak, but we'll see.
The clip seems interesting, can't wait to see how the other episodes next month will turn out.
OK now on my thoughts' on S19 Christmas
'Diesel's Ghostly Christmas' is how to start off S19 Christmas, Well from my first impression I've thought Diesel was gonna was gonna have a nightmare and be visited by spirits of scrapped engines. But it doesn't mean it's bad. I actually had a laugh at the engines disguised as Ghosts, especially Paxton, he won me over in this ep, and I loved his 4th wall moment. :D There was a flashback of "Diesel Does it Again." Quite a surprise, but kinda nice to see Whiff again. Also it's great to see Emily pull one of her signature coaches again.
Paxton was the highlight.
'Snow Place like Home' Out of the CGI NG characters, Victor is my favorite out of all of them, and I'm liking how he's and Kevin are like Father and Son. I actually thought Kevin's potrayal in this ep was kinda cute. I've thought Victor's portrayal was great. He hates the snow, but puts on a snowplow and goes out to searching for Kevin when he goes missing. Victor was given great character development.
'The Beast of Sodor' Even though Henry is portrayed as his cowardly persona, I do like the character development that was given to him. Even though Henry may not actually have a definitive character. I've usually seen Henry's character as cynical and sarcastic, but hardworking and somewhat sentimental. However I really think they need to tone down the STH/TFC humor, especially the slapstick, I feel that it's overstaying its welcome.
I didn't think 'A Cranky Christmas' was a bad episode but it's pretty dull tbh. I do like Salty singing Christmas songs and him with decorations, and some of the TAB soundtrack bits, but I don't find the ep inself engaging.
More S19 on the way
Start Your Engines Trailer
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=TMlaz_bqoRg&feature=youtu.be
It looks exciting!!!
Please give your thoughts
I'm detecting a pattern here...since season 17, we get a new character after about halfway through the season who gets to have a couple of episodes to star in himself.
Season 17 - Porter
Season 18 - Samson
Season 19- Phillip
Adding to that, I'm very excited about the new DVD. Connor and Caitlin are still some of my favorite Brenner characters, so glad to see they'll have an episode, and sharing it with Emily. Stephen as well, and we'll see if Phillip is even more unique than Porter or Samson. :)
https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-4dFllCdoSQ
We got another season 19 clip out in the open, in preparation for the new Start Your Engines DVD!
This episode looks really interesting. It's almost like a complete turn around of season 10's Thomas and the Colors, and with some improvement already being sensed! Considering James' episodes usually turn out to be really good since season 17, I'm looking forward to seeing how this will turn out. :)
Kinda surprised, no one brought back this thread. Perhaps it doesn't hurt to do so. Considering how slow and muddled S19 airings have been. Strangely, Japan has been airing new episodes, but in English. ???
Channel Links;
https://www.youtube.com/user/kaitolovethomas/videos
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCuck4VsxQanq3yTUHHbAfBA/videos
Please discuss your thoughts.
I'm not sure what in the world is wrong with season 19's broadcast. You'd think most of it would've been evenly released before this month.
Helping Hiro
This one is an alright episode. Not great, but good. I did like the flashback to Hero of the Rails and it's kind of cute to see Thomas look up to Hiro like he's his idol. Hiro's derailment was excellently done, though I don't know why anyone thought that Hiro could just brush it off and get back to work. I'm a little confused about the dialogue in this episode, too. Like why would Hiro not know why he's called the Master of the Railway, when Thomas asks him. It also bugs me when Thomas has his accident, too, that his driver and fireman just stay with him and don't go for help or something. Though it is nice that the loose ends about Hiro needing spare parts or not was tied up. Not a season 19 highlight exactly, but not bad per say. 6/10
Reds Vs. Blues
I thought this would be much like season 10's Thomas and the Colors, but I think I like this one better, albeit not by much. This episode did have a good setup, with Thomas and Edward getting more appreciation than James because of their colors. It was also amusing having Sir Topham Hatt as the referee, and seeing the opposing team root for James because of his color made things interesting. Though, I honestly felt that this episode would've been better with Edward in Thomas' place, and it was mostly predictable plot wise and in its execution. There's not much particularly remarkable about it, except for Percy referencing the show's narrator with the quote "And then there was trouble!" It is one of those more simplistic slice of life episodes that also teaches a little more about British football regulations. 7/10
Two Wheels Good
This episode definitely reminded me of Lady Hatt's Birthday Party from season 5. While I don't like this one as much as the former, it's still a very good episode. I particularly love how much human interaction was written, especially the Thin Controller and his love for bicycles. That's actually very amusing! I also liked how the Duke and Duchess got to have their different personalities on display. Who would've thought the Duke would throw so many petty tantrums like that? Not to mention I look forward to more roadway associated episodes like this. It was also a treat to see Lord Callan come back after a 12 year absence. I kind of wish though that Bertie would get a rest from getting the short end of the stick, I will say. It seems like he usually does these days. Like I said, the plot is something I've seen before, but it's done with enough uniqueness to make it stand out enough on its own. 8/10
Slow Stephen
Now, this is going to be a definite favorite for me this season, and is a good example of why Stephen is one of my favorite of the Brenner characters. Even though I'm one of the few people who don't hate The Afternoon Tea Express from season 17, this episode is a lot better. It's much better at telling the moral that being slow can be a good thing. The build up to the climax was superbly done, and was actually quite tense. It's been awhile since I've seen a Thomas episode get this suspenseful. The collapsing of the suspension bridge was incredibly executed, the way shots were angled, and the music coupled with it - absolutely epic. There's also a slight nod to season 2's Better Late Than Never, which was actually quite subtle. 10/10
Best Engine Ever
Emily seems to be getting some really good roles in episodes since season 17. This one is no exception. I've grown very fond of both Connor and Caitlin, and seeing the latter get some more depth was very welcome. I had a feeling I was going to love this episode when it was announced, and it did not disappoint. It was so great to see many of the females of Sodor put together. The moral was just right for Emily, and I appreciate how nicely the episode was written to start and setup the plot evenly. Putting Marion in was a nice treat, and it's like I said about putting a good amount of female characters in one episode - it's pretty rare in the Thomas realm. The climax though was extremely well done with Emily slowing down Caitlin from the front, and it reminded of something that was actually done in real life! Albeit with 18 wheeler trucks and not trains, but it was so action packed it kept me well entertained. Though that streamlined Emily was made into a wooden toy for a 3 second shot? Seems kinda ridiculous really...Oh yeah, I also loved Connor's little "Afternoon ladies!" with his little wink - who knew he was such a ladies' man? I really hope we get another episode like this soon. 10/10
The Little Engine Who Raced Ahead
I'm not exactly sure what to feel about Phillip so far. He didn't exactly warm up to me as well as Porter or even Samson. I think he may be a little too confident and bubbly to be admired, albeit it is kinda cute. However, I will say his design is great, and actually is one of the American prototypes to fit into Sodor's loading gauge. I also like how they refer to his basis as a box-cab, just like how us Americans would reference him. It was a nice break that they didn't start the episode with exposition about new engines coming, and just got straight to the plot. If I must be fair, this was like a shorter version of the Adventure Begins, and Phillip seems to have taken the new place as the most junior engine on the railway. Though something I will criticize is that the writers should make Gordon a little bit more compassionate. Since season 17, they've got his pompous attitude down right which is just fine for me, but they've kind of been ignoring the other side of him, and this episode kinda shows it, too. The episode would've been a lot better if that was done. So, not a great episode, but a decent one in my opinion. 7/10
Phillip to the Rescue
A bit of improvement over the previous episode. Just like with Samson last season, it's great to see the continuity with Phillip's past events already. It was also nicely done with Phillip playing off of James. I guess it was only a matter of time until James got a taste of his own medicine. Now it may be not as good as last season with Duck, but still pretty good. Though the ending scene might be a little unpleasant of Phillip not quite taking Edward's words wisely, he is more admirable in this episode, and I guess he'll develop into being less confident as time goes on. The little nod to the Adventure Begins by Edward was great, and it also shows how much Thomas himself has grown since he first arrived. I'm also happy to see much longer train consists being used. It makes the trains look much more realistic. James' derailment was extremely well done, with him smashing into the rock bridge sides. I've never seen a crash like that before in the series. Most of the time, the train hits some flimsy wood plank or something. Which brings me to something else well done - when there is a serious wreck, the engines actually show the scars of battle. If this was done 3 or more years ago, they wouldn't have one paint scratch! 8/10
Quote from: MeganekkoFury1126 on December 16, 2015, 08:39:49 PM
I'm not sure what in the world is wrong with season 19's broadcast. You'd think most of it would've been evenly released before this month.
Helping Hiro
This one is an alright episode. Not great, but good. I did like the flashback to Hero of the Rails and it's kind of cute to see Thomas look up to Hiro like he's his idol. Hiro's derailment was excellently done, though I don't know why anyone thought that Hiro could just brush it off and get back to work. I'm a little confused about the dialogue in this episode, too. Like why would Hiro not know why he's called the Master of the Railway, when Thomas asks him. It also bugs me when Thomas has his accident, too, that his driver and fireman just stay with him and don't go for help or something. Though it is nice that the loose ends about Hiro needing spare parts or not was tied up. Not a season 19 highlight exactly, but not bad per say. 6/10
Reds Vs. Blues
I thought this would be much like season 10's Thomas and the Colors, but I think I like this one better, albeit not by much. This episode did have a good setup, with Thomas and Edward getting more appreciation than James because of their colors. It was also amusing having Sir Topham Hatt as the referee, and seeing the opposing team root for James because of his color made things interesting. Though, I honestly felt that this episode would've been better with Edward in Thomas' place, and it was mostly predictable plot wise and in its execution. There's not much particularly remarkable about it, except for Percy referencing the show's narrator with the quote "And then there was trouble!" It is one of those more simplistic slice of life episodes that also teaches a little more about British football regulations. 7/10
Two Wheels Good
This episode definitely reminded me of Lady Hatt's Birthday Party from season 5. While I don't like this one as much as the former, it's still a very good episode. I particularly love how much human interaction was written, especially the Thin Controller and his love for bicycles. That's actually very amusing! I also liked how the Duke and Duchess got to have their different personalities on display. Who would've thought the Duke would throw so many petty tantrums like that? Not to mention I look forward to more roadway associated episodes like this. It was also a treat to see Lord Callan come back after a 12 year absence. I kind of wish though that Bertie would get a rest from getting the short end of the stick, I will say. It seems like he usually does these days. Like I said, the plot is something I've seen before, but it's done with enough uniqueness to make it stand out enough on its own. 8/10
Slow Stephen
Now, this is going to be a definite favorite for me this season, and is a good example of why Stephen is one of my favorite of the Brenner characters. Even though I'm one of the few people who don't hate The Afternoon Tea Express from season 17, this episode is a lot better. It's much better at telling the moral that being slow can be a good thing. The build up to the climax was superbly done, and was actually quite tense. It's been awhile since I've seen a Thomas episode get this suspenseful. The collapsing of the suspension bridge was incredibly executed, the way shots were angled, and the music coupled with it - absolutely epic. There's also a slight nod to season 2's Better Late Than Never, which was actually quite subtle. 10/10
Best Engine Ever
Emily seems to be getting some really good roles in episodes since season 17. This one is no exception. I've grown very fond of both Connor and Caitlin, and seeing the latter get some more depth was very welcome. I had a feeling I was going to love this episode when it was announced, and it did not disappoint. It was so great to see many of the females of Sodor put together. The moral was just right for Emily, and I appreciate how nicely the episode was written to start and setup the plot evenly. Putting Marion in was a nice treat, and it's like I said about putting a good amount of female characters in one episode - it's pretty rare in the Thomas realm. The climax though was extremely well done with Emily slowing down Caitlin from the front, and it reminded of something that was actually done in real life! Albeit with 18 wheeler trucks and not trains, but it was so action packed it kept me well entertained. Though that streamlined Emily was made into a wooden toy for a 3 second shot? Seems kinda ridiculous really...Oh yeah, I also loved Connor's little "Afternoon ladies!" with his little wink - who knew he was such a ladies' man? I really hope we get another episode like this soon. 10/10
The Little Engine Who Raced Ahead
I'm not exactly sure what to feel about Phillip so far. He didn't exactly warm up to me as well as Porter or even Samson. I think he may be a little too confident and bubbly to be admired, albeit it is kinda cute. However, I will say his design is great, and actually is one of the American prototypes to fit into Sodor's loading gauge. I also like how they refer to his basis as a box-cab, just like how us Americans would reference him. It was a nice break that they didn't start the episode with exposition about new engines coming, and just got straight to the plot. If I must be fair, this was like a shorter version of the Adventure Begins, and Phillip seems to have taken the new place as the most junior engine on the railway. Though something I will criticize is that the writers should make Gordon a little bit more compassionate. Since season 17, they've got his pompous attitude down right which is just fine for me, but they've kind of been ignoring the other side of him, and this episode kinda shows it, too. The episode would've been a lot better if that was done. So, not a great episode, but a decent one in my opinion. 7/10
Phillip to the Rescue
A bit of improvement over the previous episode. Just like with Samson last season, it's great to see the continuity with Phillip's past events already. It was also nicely done with Phillip playing off of James. I guess it was only a matter of time until James got a taste of his own medicine. Now it may be not as good as last season with Duck, but still pretty good. Though the ending scene might be a little unpleasant of Phillip not quite taking Edward's words wisely, he is more admirable in this episode, and I guess he'll develop into being less confident as time goes on. The little nod to the Adventure Begins by Edward was great, and it also shows how much Thomas himself has grown since he first arrived. I'm also happy to see much longer train consists being used. It makes the trains look much more realistic. James' derailment was extremely well done, with him smashing into the rock bridge sides. I've never seen a crash like that before in the series. Most of the time, the train hits some flimsy wood plank or something. Which brings me to something else well done - when there is a serious wreck, the engines actually show the scars of battle. If this was done 3 or more years ago, they wouldn't have one paint scratch! 8/10
i thought your suggestion about Edward doing Thomas' role might make him out of character unless he does Percy's short role or act as the wise steady engine. Also, inspired by his track master model, I hope there is a midquel episode for Philip to the rescue where Philip who takes empty trucks to the quarry, which will be the blue mountain quarry like one of the wagons his track master model, where he learns his limitations when taking the now fully loaded slate trucks.
What I mean by that is to make the episode to fit Edward and James, not just throw him in and expect it to be appropriate. The reason I said that is because it not only would've been a perfect opportunity to make a homage episode to Old Iron, but also not have an episode where Thomas has to be in a spotlight for a change. As much as I like this season and the past two, they still need to cut down how much they throw Thomas in.
A little late, but hey.....
I often enjoy discussions over the TV Series
Helping Hiro was pretty dull, the crash and damage done to Hiro was great. Though the thing that gets to me was the Master of the Railway dialogue and Hiro not knowing why. But the reflection off Hiro's livery really shows how Arc has improved in their lighting.
Percy's 4th Wall, need I say more?? :D
I've wondered on how they would utilized Stephen outside of Ulfstad Castle, but this ep felt like an improved squeal to the Afternoon Tea Express.
I think my favorite out of the batch would have to be "Best Engines Ever." Connor/Caitlin always get the fast paced often exciting episodes. I do like how this ep focuses specifically on female characters without feeling like it had to aimed at the girl audience. Funny how the ep was implying girl troubles, though. :P And yes Connor's line. ::)
Philip
I'm not sure what to say about Philip as a character. His design though I thought it was German at first. I can't say whether I say that Philip is endearing or annoying. ???
Does Gordon hate Philip or just dislike him greatly?
Huh, we got more season 19 to talk about!
The Other Side of the Mountain
First off, very happy Bertie's classic theme made a return. This must be the season to get back into the old music. Second, I'm glad that this episode on Thomas and Bertie where it didn't involve them racing. It did feel like an episode that came out of season 2 or 3. It does keep the person viewing wondering if Bertie was telling the truth or not about what is on the other side. It's also pretty naturally handled how Thomas gets more and more curious, and more and more frustrated. The big derailment was a little over the top, but it did serve its purpose for the story. Still enjoy how the engines show damage after these big wrecks. I like that Butch was utilized for the story. This episode is a good example of how the writers can nicely handle road characters as well as rail ones. Though, the fantasy ending feels a little pointless. It's just kind of there. It's a little funny, though, I'll give it that. 8/10
Thomas the Babysitter
I noticed that pretty much the whole episode occurred in the same day. In fact, maybe a couple hours. Been awhile since that happened. I did enjoy the 90's style montage of Thomas going through the hours of his run enduring the baby's crying. Also been awhile since Maithwaite appeared in Arc's animation, not to mention the classic waterwheel. I also like that Annie and Clarabel prevented the episode from going down a familiar bad plotline, and Thomas came to his senses very quickly. The ending is the strongest point in the episode. The music which feels a bit like Blue Grass infant music, the comedy of torturing Annie and Clarabel with more baby riding, and the human interaction of the workman Albert and his family. Somehow I imagine that's how my parents gave me my name. The only thing I found odd was why the mother and baby get back on after Thomas turns around. It really doesn't give an explanation. Other than that, this is still a great episode. 9/10
No Help at All
Well, we have this season's Bill and Ben episode, and it also has Marion and Timothy. Guess it's getting in the swing of one episode for each of the "supporting groups" on Sodor, much like the classic seasons. I was a little worried this would be like Timothy and the Rainbow Truck, which happens to be my least favorite episode of season 18, but I was fortunately wrong. I love that they went back to focusing on Timothy's straight laced trait. It is arguably his most distinctive quality. Sort of like the Josh to Bill and Ben's Drake. Bill and Ben are just as obnoxious and entertaining as ever. I was very pleased to see Porter get a good role, too, let alone see him and Timothy work together. I think this is the first time a classic song has been utilized in a regular episode, and I loved it. It helped Down by the Docks is one of my favorite songs. Not to mention a little nod to We Make a Team Together. If you also listen carefully, this episode pretty much takes place at the same time as Emily's repairs in Best Engine Ever, Mavis' in Den and Dart, and Salty's trip in Salty All at Sea. Glad to see the writers are very consistent with continuity. Plus, for once, Sir Topham Hatt is played seriously this episode, instead of a butt monkey. I can't really point out any flaws really, except maybe Bill and Ben repeatedly bumping into the lines of trucks. It does feel a bit...odd. Nonetheless, this is going to be another favorite this season. 9.5/10
Quote from: MeganekkoFury1126 on January 21, 2016, 12:01:45 PM
Huh, we got more season 19 to talk about!
The Other Side of the Mountain
First off, very happy Bertie's classic theme made a return. This must be the season to get back into the old music. Second, I'm glad that this episode on Thomas and Bertie where it didn't involve them racing. It did feel like an episode that came out of season 2 or 3. It does keep the person viewing wondering if Bertie was telling the truth or not about what is on the other side. It's also pretty naturally handled how Thomas gets more and more curious, and more and more frustrated. The big derailment was a little over the top, but it did serve its purpose for the story. Still enjoy how the engines show damage after these big wrecks. I like that Butch was utilized for the story. This episode is a good example of how the writers can nicely handle road characters as well as rail ones. Though, the fantasy ending feels a little pointless. It's just kind of there. It's a little funny, though, I'll give it that. 8/10
Thomas the Babysitter
I noticed that pretty much the whole episode occurred in the same day. In fact, maybe a couple hours. Been awhile since that happened. I did enjoy the 90's style montage of Thomas going through the hours of his run enduring the baby's crying. Also been awhile since Maithwaite appeared in Arc's animation, not to mention the classic waterwheel. I also like that Annie and Clarabel prevented the episode from going down a familiar bad plotline, and Thomas came to his senses very quickly. The ending is the strongest point in the episode. The music which feels a bit like Blue Grass infant music, the comedy of torturing Annie and Clarabel with more baby riding, and the human interaction of the workman Albert and his family. Somehow I imagine that's how my parents gave me my name. The only thing I found odd was why the mother and baby get back on after Thomas turns around. It really doesn't give an explanation. Other than that, this is still a great episode. 9/10
No Help at All
Well, we have this season's Bill and Ben episode, and it also has Marion and Timothy. Guess it's getting in the swing of one episode for each of the "supporting groups" on Sodor, much like the classic seasons. I was a little worried this would be like Timothy and the Rainbow Truck, which happens to be my least favorite episode of season 18, but I was fortunately wrong. I love that they went back to focusing on Timothy's straight laced trait. It is arguably his most distinctive quality. Sort of like the Josh to Bill and Ben's Drake. Bill and Ben are just as obnoxious and entertaining as ever. I was very pleased to see Porter get a good role, too, let alone see him and Timothy work together. I think this is the first time a classic song has been utilized in a regular episode, and I loved it. It helped Down by the Docks is one of my favorite songs. Not to mention a little nod to We Make a Team Together. If you also listen carefully, this episode pretty much takes place at the same time as Emily's repairs in Best Engine Ever, Mavis' in Den and Dart, and Salty's trip in Salty All at Sea. Glad to see the writers are very consistent with continuity. Plus, for once, Sir Topham Hatt is played seriously this episode, instead of a butt monkey. I can't really point out any flaws really, except maybe Bill and Ben repeatedly bumping into the lines of trucks. It does feel a bit...odd. Nonetheless, this is going to be another favorite this season. 9.5/10
Are 'The Other Side of the Mountain', Thomas and the Babysitter' and 'No Help at All' Episode titles from Series 19?
Yes, Jacob, hence why they're in this topic: Season 19.
They're online now.
Quote from: MeganekkoFury1126 on January 21, 2016, 01:55:26 PM
Yes, Jacob, hence why they're in this topic: Season 19.
They're online now.
I have not seen Series 19 yet. Has the UK version of Series 19 aired yet? I prefer the UK version of Thomas & Friends as I live in the UK.
I figured that since this season basically finished airing all of its episodes I would share my thoughts on this season as a whole rather than each individual episode.
Season 19 was... An interesting season to say the least compared to the likes of season 17 and 18. It was the first season in a while to take place before the years special which wasn't a bad thing but at times I felt that there wasn't as much the writers had to work with like how they did last season. There were a few clever and original ideas such as the first double-length episode as well as an episode taking place around the same time as three other stories. It was also a lot of fun seeing some of the characters who hardly had any attention in the last two seasons get a episodes to themselves such as Henry, Stephen, and Salty while putting other characters who had a lot of exposure before aside such as Duck, Marion, and the narrow gauge engines. It shows that the writers want to give balance to characters that they enjoy writing stories about equal treatment. All these qualities really make this season very admirable and even though not a whole lot of the episodes were that incredible, the ones that were are simply amazing.
That being said this season definitely had a few flaws, and some were more glaring than others. One of them was Phillip. Yeah, I'm sure some of you saw this coming, but I don't think he is a particularly bad character but he is nothing unique compared to other characters who have a similar persona such as Kevin, Charlie, or even in his earlier days, Thomas. There were also some episodes that really struggled as far as season 19 is concerned. Some I found to be very undewhelming, others were very over-the-top with over-the-top moments. The forced Sir Topham Hatt humor got old very quickly. A lot of times not only did the forced humor do nothing for the episode but it even made episodes worse.
As much as I love what Arc has done with the show, I will say that while I do like season 19 I found it to be a hit and miss compared to the last two seasons. The show took some chances with the season and while some worked and others didn't I can certainly say that for the most part I admire that they tried to do that and I am interested in seeing where season 20 will be heading from there.
And just for fun here are my top 5 favorites and least favorites.
Favorites:
1. No Help At All
2. Snow Place Like Home
3. Den and Dart
4. The Truth About Toby
5. Diesels Ghostly Christmas
Least favorites:
1. Henry Spots Trouble
2. Rocky Rescue
3. The Other Side of the Mountain
4. Thomas the Babysitter
5. Helping Hiro
At least TFC was not much of a scolder than in S17 and S18, and even admitted some of his wrongs, particularly in Who's Geoffrey? Where he teaches Thomas about owing up to mistakes by using his experience.
I gotta agree Chaz. Looking back, some episodes I might give a little lower than I thought, though some may get higher.
With the two new episodes released recently, Rocky Rescue and Goodbye Sir Topham Hatt, they're both pretty meh in my opinion, the former more so.
Agreed, there are plenty of noticeably weak episodes like Rocky Rescue, Henry Spots Trouble, Helping Hiro, and Salty All at Sea.
There are also okay ones like Red Vs. Blues, Cranky Christmas, and the Phillip episodes.
But we also got really stand out ones, like Best Engine Ever, No Help at All, Slow Stephen and Den and Dart.
I will say overall, season 19 has been a bit more consistent compared to season 17 and 18, but it did take awhile before it really felt as if it stepped up its game compared to the two predecessors.
Personally, if I could sum it up concisely, it feels like season 19 is to season 17 and 18 what season 3 was to season 1 and 2. It didn't introduce too much groundbreaking material or new characters, but still offered a solid list of episodes that seemed to do more with less.
That being said, I am DEFINITELY looking forward to what potential they can unlock in season 20. We have a lot to look forward to after all: Daisy, Ryan, Skiff, Rex, Bert, Mike, Donald and Douglas, and that's just what we know. :D