Thanks guys just read something on smoke for N SCALE and wanted to ask about it. Sounded interesting but I know its a mess. Ron
Please read the Forum Code of Conduct >>Click Here <<
This section allows you to view all posts made by this member. Note that you can only see posts made in areas you currently have access to.
Show posts MenuQuote from: skipgear on December 11, 2010, 11:15:34 PMI know the tutorial shows the light mountain getting a small decoder in the boiler. Is the Micro Tsunami two big for the boiler? If so that must be why your saying to put a smaller one in the boiler and one in the tender to do both jobs.
You are making this much more complex than it needs to be.
#1 - Up to this point, all N scale Bachmann loco's with DCC have the decoder soldered in. None of thier installs use a plug.
#2 - There is not room in the tender for two decoders and a speaker, especially considering the huge thing that Bachmann call's a decoder in their DCC loco's.
#3 - The light mountain is designed for a small decoder to be installed in the boiler. The heavy mountain is designed so that the decoder installs in the tender.
#4 - Adding sound to the light mountain will require either dual decoders (a small one in the boiler and a sound unit in the tender) or a sound unit in the tender and wires from the tender to the loco for headlight and motor control.
Quote from: skipgear on December 10, 2010, 05:33:47 PMNow thats a thought! The decoder in the heavy mountain, I guess, is only for motor. I guess no sound section in the decoder. It must be in there like the light mountain install tutorial. So just remove it and do the total with one Tsunami! Than the light mountain would be the same install. Tony's trains thought there was a plug in the light mountain or heavy mountain to plug a decoder into. I don't think so. Ron
If you are going to put sound in the Heavy Mountain, just eliminate the factory decoder. They are not the best decoder to begin with. All the current N scale sound decoders have motor control already and even the MRC decoders have better motor control than the factory Bachmann decoder.
Quote from: skipgear on November 24, 2010, 07:17:40 PMQuote from: simkon on November 24, 2010, 06:37:09 PMQuote from: skipgear on November 24, 2010, 06:05:29 PMYep, did not check the Athearn catalog...besides the 3 Athearn offerings there is only the BLI E6/7/8/9 (which I mentioned), the Walthers 2-8-8-2 (which I mentioned), however, I neglected to mention the BLI PAs, I missed it in the catalog I guess... Hey skip, since you think the install is so easy why don't you volunteer to do the install for Ron at no charge?
The above....
...Adding sound in a Light Mountain is not too hard although you need to run wires beween the loco and the tender unless you do a dual decoder setup.
The 2-8-8-2 does not have the Vanderbilt tender from your original post, it is very specifically a N&W Y-3. N&W wasn't really fond of Vanderbilts. The Walthers Y-3 happens to be the best sounding/running N scale loco yet. I love mine.
I consider the E6, E7, E8/9 all unique loco's because they have very different car bodies.
Sorry, would like to help but I have too many other projects on the bench right now, but it's not that hard to do. Here is a sound install in a Trix 2-10-0. The tender is the same as the K4 tender which is smaller than the USRA tender used on the Light Mountain. The lead box is the speaker enclosure.
The IM AC-12 could also be considered a sound unit as the Digitrax SDN144 decoder will drop into it with no modifications. Truely a 15 minute install at worst.
Edit - Forgot a few available sound locos:
Kato Kobo GS4
Kato Kobo NYC RDC Jet
ConCor offered PA/B sets where the B unit was crammed full of sound decoder.
Almost every modern Kato loco now has drop in sound available for it from MRC and a few from Digitrax. They can be installed in a matter of minutes.
Quote from: skipgear on November 24, 2010, 10:57:10 PM
Actually no, you just need the sound decoder. It controls motor and sound. John Columbo has had great luck using a dual decoder setup, one in the loco, one in the tender but for your first sound install, just a sound decoder in the tender is simpler to setup.
If you are not using DCC, then the dual decoder system will not work very well anyhow.