News:

Please read the Forum Code of Conduct   >>Click Here <<

Main Menu

Bachmann Flying Scotsman Thread

Started by GordonPacific04, July 19, 2025, 10:57:10 AM

Previous topic - Next topic

Armada Starscream

Quote from: Awesometrain77 on July 30, 2025, 11:51:06 AM
Quote from: harrison05 on July 27, 2025, 09:42:57 PM
Quote from: Zorran202 on July 27, 2025, 12:52:49 PMI find it ironic that even the Flying Scotsman Tenders that did show up in Season 3 had the correct lining on it, but not the CGI render. I'd imagine that if they do correct the lining on the tenders, then overall it'll be a perfect model of the T&F Flying Scotsman.



Also his model tenders had the correct wheel configuration on the tenders, I still don't know why they didn't just give the tenders 4 wheels in cgi...

To be honest, yeah . I wonder if they would also change that to have Spencer's tender, be reused . 
I'm sure they could get away with this as sir Handel had extra detailing so modifying Scotsman wouldn't be too far off .

I would like for Bachmann Flying Scotsmans Tenders to have 8 wheels as well, and they do have the Spencer tender to use as at least a basis to start with.

I have also have had a thought that I wanted to bring up that could make both sides happy.

If Bachmann ultimately decides to make Flying Scotsman screen accurate in CGI with the 6-wheeled tenders, maybe something they could also do would be to modify the Spencer Tender into 8-wheeled Flying Scotsmans Tenders, and then release them as separate products meant to supplement the Bachmann Flying Scotsman. Call them something along the lines "Flying Scotsman Tender 1" and "Flying Scotsman Tender 2." The 6-wheeled CGI Tenders would then come with the Flying Scotsman Model, making it screen accurate to the CGI series, but there would also be Model series accurate 8-wheeled tenders available for purchase for those who want to go the extra mile. This would also give Bachmann an additional set of 2 more products they could sell, and the 8-wheel tenders might also appeal to non-Thomas Modelers who would want an 8 wheeled tender for without having to buy a whole engine.

I don't know if this would be a good idea, but I wanted to at least put this on the table.

JLK2707


Awesometrain77

It's confirmed Scottsman will have both tenders that are both new tools . Overall really hyped to this happen I can't belive he is happening can't wait till we see a prototype.

It seems they will be 6 wheels .which is shame but I can't imagine them making a similar tender to Spencer as a complete new tool .
 

MrNormalDraws

Quote from: DustyMarie53! on August 11, 2025, 08:26:04 PMThey also specifically confirmed it would reuse Gordon's chassis for both the the engine and the tender. Not sure how I feel about this. But it worked for Stanley so I'll hold any judgement until wee sit

Are they gonna redo the siderods for Scotsman? I feel like the old rods look really outdated. Maybe this might encourage modelers to use them for Gordon like with Stanley using Thomas' chassis.

Awesometrain77

Scottsman will have 6 wheels confirmed.
His couplings will either be a drawbar or hook and loop for the water tender .
Both tender and the engine will be a new tool .

GordonPacific04

#35
So a couple things confirmed about Flying Scotsman in today's Thomas Tuesday stream.

- Will be Reusing Gordon's chassis
- Body and tenders will be new toolings
- Matt said he would ideally like to have the standard hook and loop couplers between the tenders, but will ultimately come down to what's most cost effective.
- Will look like how he did in CGI, so the tenders will have 6 wheels

In my opinion, don't care too much about having 6 wheels on the tenders, though I do hope we'll have the standard hook and loop couplers between the tenders. I'm a bit bummed that he'll be using Gordon's chassis, as the siderods are too thick and it's a bit underscale. I would have preferred he use Spencer's chassis because it counters all of those points, but maybe the giant eye mech had something to do with it. It is what it is though.
Fantasising of Bachmann Hiro, Harvey, Diesel 10, Whiff, Rocky, The Works Unit Coach, and Large Scale Edward.

TrainFan97

Just like how Stanley recycled Thomas' chassis, Flying Scotsman will recycle Gordon's chassis, which will be the more cost-effective way to produce him, though his tenders and body will be new toolings. It's a shame that Mallard never appeared in the TV Series. Otherwise, he would've been a simple repaint using Spencer's tooling.

The coupling between the two tenders should hopefully be hook-and-loop, so Flying Scotsman could be run with or without the second tender, but it will come down to what's more cost-effective, so it may end up being a draw-bar instead.

Hoping he will still have the proper lining on his tenders, rather than the Fowler tender lining. They can fix things after the first painted sample gets shown. It's happened before, since the first painted sample we see isn't usually final.
My wishlist for HO Scale: Stepney, BoCo, Fernando, Norman, Den, Dart, Porter, Samson, Timothy, Whiff, Hiro, Winston, and Green Salty.
My wishlist for N Scale: Edward, Spencer, Flying Scotsman, Duck, Oliver, Mavis, Sidney, 'Arry and Bert.

Kemptown Branch

Quote from: GordonPacific04 on August 12, 2025, 07:31:45 PMI'm a bit bummed that he'll be using Gordon's chassis, as the siderods are too thick.

Bachmann did make new siderods for Stanley despite reusing Thomas' chassis, so maybe they'll be able to do the same for Flying Scotsman.
Hoping for Edward and the Milk Tanker in N Scale!